Geoffrey or just Geoff is a member of the Box Canyon Commune, led by Eli. He used to be a big hedge fund manager who was doing well enough for himself to buy a beach house on Antigua, but one day he could no longer stand the grind and joined the commune to find true happiness.
Geoffrey divorced Nicole Reed, a fellow commune member, two years ago but never quite moved on, as evidenced by his uncharacteristically violent reaction to Redneck 1, the lout disrespecting her at the fruit stand. When he finds out through her emails that she is going to meet stranger Dan Cooper in the city, he is worried for her but decides not to say anything. However, after Nicole sees Cooper get killed and Geoffrey reveals in the Barn of Truth that he knew about the meeting, Lassiter and Juliet construe his worry as jealousy and go to search his house. They find Cooper's body in the shed and arrest Geoffrey on the charge of murder, but Shawn saves the day by deducing that it was in fact Eli who murdered Cooper in order to keep him from outing him as a crook stealing from the commune members. With Eli gone and everyone's money returned, Geoffrey is planning on buying the commune's property together with Dot to ensure their little piece of paradise can continue to prosper.