Eldon is a former Bosseigh High classmate of Shawn and Gus's, graduating alongside them as part of the Class of '95. He takes his "brand new wife" Stephanie to his 13-year class reunion, where his high school girlfriend Mindy Howland ("all four years") introduces them to her date Lassiter. He seems quite sceptical when she mentions he's a cop and asks "You ever shoot anybody?"
Some time later Mindy asks Lassiter to make a move on Stephanie because she wants to get back with Eldon and needs "that painted whore out of the picture," and she gets quite angry when he refuses that "one teensy-weensy little tiny favor."